Dog Bites in Children Surge during Coronavirus Disease-2019: A Case for Enhanced Prevention

As the world grapples with the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, unforeseen sequela and public health implications continue to mount. Hospitals battle to keep patients alive while balancing worker safety amid rationing of personal protective equipment. Researchers race to discover a vaccine while politicians, communities, and neighborhoods debate shelter-in-place and social distancing regulations. Families experience financial devastation and loss of loved ones while parents and grandparents become full-time home care providers and educators. Throughout all the chaos, uncertainty, and increased sharing of home spaces are our children and domesticated pets who are also, albeit unexpected, victims of COVID-19 sequelae and stresses. Canine companions being particularly susceptible to these stresses, as they live amongst the ever-present angst of their caregivers, thus complicating their usual steadfast interactions.

Relationships with our companion dogs not only bring us joy, but science has also demonstrated that even brief positive interactions with dogs can decrease human stress and anxiety.1 For children living in a home with a dog, the benefits include increased responsibility and compassion, a sense of security and pride, and even positive impacts to the immune system. Potential risks of living with a dog, however, also exist—especially for the most vulnerable, younger, family members.

Dog bites cause significant harm to millions of people in the US each year.2 Children have the highest risk of dog bites, with large incidences and greater severity of injuries. Of the nearly 340 000 emergency department (ED) visits for dog bite injuries each year—equating to more than 900 per day—more than 40% of the victims are children and adolescents.3

Families with children and dogs are undergoing unique challenges during the COVID-19 pandemic. Caregivers have the additional tension of children staying at home 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, for weeks and now months on end; little to no reprieve afforded by out-of-home activities such as school, playdates, parks, or libraries exist. Meanwhile, dogs in these households are presumably also experiencing untoward stress. Not only do the dogs have increased exposure to children, which may or may not be supervised, dogs may be experiencing “emotional contagion”—a state in which companion dogs mirror the emotions and stress levels of their human caregivers.4 Together, these unique circumstances can increase the likelihood of adverse interactions between children and their dogs.

Since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic and governmental directives to shelter-in-place, dog bite rates seem to be increasing. Our children’s hospital has experienced an almost 3-fold increase in rates of visits to the pediatric ED because of dog bites since our statewide “stay-at-home” order was instituted (Figure). High rates have persisted even amid recent relaxing of these regulations. To date, our institution’s incidence of ED visits for dog bites is more than double that of summer rates, when these injuries are typically most common.

The reasons for the increased number of dog bites during the COVID-19 pandemic are multifactorial. Contributing factors may include increased child-dog exposure earlier in the year as a result of shelter-in-place regulations (ie, exposures similar to summer months when children are ordinarily out of school), greater dog stress given increased child presence and amplified household stress, and decreased adult supervision of children around dogs, due to new and competing home responsibilities for parents and caregivers.

We hypothesize that our experience of increased dog bite incidence is not unique. There are currently 82 million children and 77 million pet dogs6 living in the US—all experiencing some variation of shelter-in-place restriction. Thus, now more than ever, we urge healthcare providers, public health professionals, and injury control experts to strengthen and increase advocacy and educational efforts for prevention in order to minimize dog bites. We must remind families that children, especially those ages 5-9 years, have the highest incidence of dog bites. Infants and younger children have a higher likelihood of bites to the head and neck. Importantly, most dog bites occur by the family dog or another known dog. Dogs are more likely to bite in circumstances of resource guarding (such as in protecting their property, toys, and food) or if they are ill, excited, or frightened. Although evidence-based and expert-guided recommendations to prevent dog bites exist (Table), the most important strategy to prevent dog bites is to always, always, supervise infants and children when they are near a dog.7,8

-Cinnamon A. Dixon, DO, MPH1 and Rakesh D. Mistry, MD, MS2

*Read the full article in the Journal of Pediatrics with table and references here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Ohio AAP Practice Manager Discussion Board - Disclaimer

This page is for practice managers and office employees to discuss issues they’re experiencing in their practices. Many problems that we hear about can help other practices, so we invite you to share best practices by posting issues and by responding to issues other practices are experiencing. This page is monitored by the Ohio AAP. Advice and opinions expressed on these discussion boards are the views of the poster and do not necessarily reflect the views of Ohio AAP. If you have any issues, questions, or feedback, please contact Melanie Farkas.